Searchmetrics Study: Did Google Shopping Really Gain an Unfair Advantage over its Competitors in the EU?

Analysis of search data shows Google Shopping gained 300% visibility in recent years even as competitor visibility declined. EU’s case may not be clear-cut

London, U.K., September 28, 2017 – With Google now agreeing to concede to the EU’s antitrust action by creating a standalone unit for its shopping services and allowing rivals to bid for ads shown there, a new study examines whether Google Shopping did in fact gain an illegal advantage over other price comparison sites. And does the search company have a legitimate case in appealing the EU decision?

The research by Searchmetrics reveals that the appearance of Google Shopping ad units in the search results increased by over 300% on desktop and mobile in the UK, Germany and France in recent years. At the same time, the average search visibility* of other large online comparison sites** dropped by over 50% on desktop and nearly 30% on mobile.

While the data lends support to the European Commission’s claim that Google did unfairly favour its own search results over competitors’, it’s not enough of a smoking gun to back up all the EU’s charges and the proposed fine, said Marcus Tober, Searchmetrics founder and CTO.

“Whilst the European Commission’s statements are quite clear-cut and one-sided, our data indicates that the true picture is probably much more diverse,” Tober said. “The search performance of both Google Shopping and its competitors vary over time, from country to country and for individual comparison websites ‒ and that doesn’t quite fit with Google making a consistent, targeted effort to penalize comparison shopping services across the region.”

Within the hotly contested online comparison-shopping business, understanding why some companies are winning and others losing is not clear-cut, he said.

“There are many factors involved that could have been impacting the comparison sites’ search visibility. For example, we found some evidence to suggest, as Google has claimed in its defence, that some of the loss of search performance for the comparison sites could be connected to the growing popularity of Amazon and eBay. Though here again, we see different results in each country and it’s probably not as straightforward as Google wants us to believe either,” Tober said.

Given the scale of the EU’s action and the potentially wider implications for other sectors, the independent report released today by Searchmetrics takes a critical look at the European Commission’s main statements, and analyses to what extent they are supported by Searchmetrics’ data. With the largest historical database of Google search results in the industry, the company is uniquely positioned to provide an expert view.

Five important findings from the analysis are summarized underneath.

1. Google saw a considerable, yet uneven rise in Google Shopping appearances in desktop searches
Between March 2013 and June 2017, the proportion of desktop search results for which at least one Google Shopping Unit (also known as Google Product Listing Ads) appears has increased by +327% overall in the three countries, France, Germany and UK. There was a +386% rise in Germany, +382% in the UK and +164% in France. This is based on a recurring analysis of Shopping Units displayed for about 1 million search terms (keywords) per country that Searchmetrics tracks per week.

However, while the overall trend shows a rise in Google Shopping Units over the period, growth is by no means steady; it is characterized by a significant increase in Q1 2014 (when Google introduced a paid only shopping service) and a significant decrease in Q2 of 2016. In between, the percentage of keywords with a Google Shopping Unit was relatively stable.

2. An overall fall in Desktop Search visibility for Google’s competitors
An analysis of 10 large competitor online comparison sites in each of the three countries found their combined Google search visibility* (on desktops) dropped by 58% overall between March 2013 and June 2017. In France, the leading comparison sites experienced a visibility drop of 79%; in Germany 50%; and in the UK, 30%.

3. Comparison sites more likely to appear on page 4 or 5 where searchers seldom look
Around half of all appearances of the large comparison sites studied in Germany and France were on page 4 and 5 of Google (desktop results), where searchers are less inclined to look. In the UK, it was 42.3%. Just 6.6% in France, 11.1% in Germany and 16.9% in the UK were on page 1.

In contrast, Google Shopping ads generally appeared on the first page – either above or at the side of the organic search results (where research suggests 92% of search traffic comes from).

However, since January 2015, the analysis suggests the percentage of comparison sites ranking on pages 1, 2 and 3 increased slightly, while those ranking on pages 4 and 5 has fell.

4. Amazon and eBay could have contributed to comparison sites’ drop
One of Google’s defenses is that the comparison sites’ decline in search results is down due to the popularity of platforms such as Amazon and eBay, not because of any unfair advantage to Google Shopping. Searchmetrics’ analysis of the search results during 2013 to 2017 revealed the following:

In France, and’s combined visibility in search results increased while the comparison sites’ visibility fell, providing support for Google’s defence

In Germany, and’s combined visibility remained more stable than that of the German comparison sites. However, in 2013 and first half of 2014 the two online marketplaces did display visibility gains while the comparison sites’ visibility declined.

In the UK, there appeared to be no recognisable relationship between the combined visibility of and and that of the comparison services.

5. Mobile appearances of Google Shopping increased while combined visibility of competitors fell
Searchmetrics analysis of Google’s mobile search results from Feb 2015 to Jun 2017 reveals that the number of keywords for which there was at least one Google shopping ad unit increased by +307% for the three countries combined.

In the same period, the mobile visibility of Google Shopping’s competitors in the three markets shows an aggregated 28% drop – however that consists of slight increases in visibility in France and UK (+16% and +11% respectively), and a larger 33% visibility fall in Germany.

To download the full report, “SERP INTEGRATION STUDY: GOOGLE SHOPPING, Investigating a possible impact of Google Shopping on the organic search visibility of comparison shopping services” visit:

*How desktop and mobile search visibility is measured in the analysis

The measure of search visibility used in the analysis is Searchmetrics’ SEO Visibility score, an index score which quantifies how prominently a website appears in search results. It is based on the desktop and mobile organic rankings of the keywords that Searchmetrics tracks in each country every week. The calculation for the SEO Visibility score is based on:

  • The number of times a domain appears in the search engine results pages (SERPs) across the keyword set
  • Its prominence within those SERPs (a higher ranking equates to a higher visibility score)
  • The competitiveness of the keyword (higher search volumes equate to a higher visibility score)

**The online comparison sites that were included within the analysis are:


About Searchmetrics
We are your pathfinder to content that uniquely matches user intent with the deep learning insights of the Searchmetrics SuiteTM and Searchmetrics Content Experience platforms. Search has evolved into a data-driven field that requires powerful tools to guide companies through discovery, optimization and measurement of engaging storytelling.

There’s only one search and content development platform that owns its data: Searchmetrics, the world’s #1 SEO and content performance platform. We don’t rely on data from third parties. Our historical database spans five years and contains over 250 billion pieces of information, such as keyword rankings, search terms, social links and backlinks. It includes global, mobile and local data covering organic and paid search, as well as social media. We have the largest global reach of any search platform, crawling the web every day in more than 130 countries.

Searchmetrics monitors and reveals the full business available to you online. We provide our customers with a competitive advantage and help them to identify new business opportunities by exposing the content consumers are engaging with on industry and competitors’ sites. Our SEO Visibility Score − trusted by reputable media sources such as The New York Times, Bloomberg and The Guardian − reliably indicates your online presence.

We provide the insights our customers need to deliver results. Searchmetrics guides SEOs and content marketers with suggestions for creating content that improves relevance and boosts conversions. It shows the connection between social media links and overall engagement. And its analytics make clear which content performs the best and how an organization’s content performs against its competitors’.

With Marcus Tober, one of the top 10 SEO minds in the world, leading Searchmetrics’ product development, we have over 100,000 users worldwide, many of whom are respected brands such as T-Mobile, eBay and Siemens. They all depend on Searchmetrics and our 12 years of product innovation to maximize their online performance.

More information:

Media Contact
Uday Radia
CloudNine PR Agency
+44 (0)7940 584161

Have any Question or Comment?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.



TRIO STEEL IS ONE OF THE MOST TRUSTED BRAND AND LEADING EXPORTER AND SUPPLIER OF CARBON STEEL, ALLOY STEEL & STAINLESS STEEL PIPES & PIPE FITTINGS MATERIAL. Triosteel is one of the leading Suppliers and Exporters of API 5L Pipe in Singapore. Triosteel also Exports to many countries like Indonesia, Iran, Saudi Arabia & many more. An API 5L pipe is manufactured by adhering to the specifications laid down by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 3183.


buy! buy! CHEAP! Telefonie VoIP CHEAP! buy! buy! CHEAP!


buy! buy! CHEAP! Telefonie VoIP CHEAP! buy! buy! CHEAP!


For the 2012 MLB period, we found an totals forecast Joao’s Renowned Over/Under João Zorro Gonçalves, Zcode Totals Pro, System of the time with progressions that have been successful over 98 98% ... We eventually perfected our over/under program ( Zcodesystemexclusive ), although it h-AS has brought years of investigation. Five Steps to Making a Winning MLB Method: 1. Execute appropriate cash management tools. 2. MLB rules that are comprehend. 3.Extensive testing back to make sure successful longterm results ...


There is always a challenge when you're dealing with the Foreign Exchange Market. That's just the nature of the beast. The best thing you can do is to learn about how the market operates as a whole so that you will be ready to meet these challenges. iq option penipu Never be misled by any profit gains in binary options. This is the number-one way traders end up losing their money and ultimately failing. Remember that the same things that make you laugh can make you cry in this market, and you can lose that $700.


Learning Polish has never been this fun and easy as with our podcasts Learn Polish with Polishpod101 Start today and become conversational in Polish in no time


The Best Website Agen Poker Resmi Terpercaya come join


Do you need edmonton phone systems service ? Call complete communications today!


High-tech solutions for easy start-up of your IPTV/OTT-business



If you want to purchase not only one item, you have a chance to enjoy privileges. There is a sale’ tab on the site which offers a fantastic range of reduced counterfeit watches and accessories, such as sunglasses, cufflinks, watch straps and pens. Luxury Jewelry Replica At MCA.MN On Sale You get a 5% discount if you buy two pieces, this discount increases to 10% if you buy 4 pieces or more. There is free international shipping on all orders on this site. We also offer customers a free return anytime with a 100% money back guarantee.